[Publib] Intellectual freedom issues and questions

[Jim Brundirks]

In my local library we filter our internet access because we have a bank of
computers that are for all patrons. Minors have access to these computers
and would be able to view adult material if unfiltered. This would be in
violation of the CIPA. Because the filter applies to all patrons, doesn't it
restrict intellectual freedom? In almost all of the large libraries I have
been in have unfiltered computers for adults. Although some would object to
public facilities being used to view such things the Office of Intellectual
Freedom within the ALA says ""Intellectual Freedom is the right of every
individual to both seek and receive information from all points of view
without restriction." Aren't we ruining these rights while protecting
others? What is a small town library to do?

Also since we are restricting access of some things to minors, who is to say
that some parents want restricted access to other things that they find
objectionable. Different views on sexual orientation or religion for
example. How can you balance the concerns of parents while still ensuring a
minor's right to intellectual freedom? Should we also restrict access to
minors access to sexually oriented material in print too? If certain content
is so objectionable, why should anyone, including adults, be able to view it
in a public place? Shouldn't libraries be free to create their own internet
regulations without the involvement of the federal government? Does the CIPA
essentially represent, or could be interpreted as, holding education funding
hostage in order to restrict access by minors to what it deems to be
'pornography'?
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.webjunction.org/wjlists/publib/attachments/20080223/dd3bbf49/attachment.htm